Okay... Added Port Fix and seems to work now. Seems weird that this would work, but when I had both firewalls down, it did not work.
Suggestion - Option to force a refresh/restart of service via the Synergy window instead of this or a force re-test. I still don't understand how allowing the port, but not the application unless it was one of the other 2 listed. I only dealt with the Synergy2 and Synergys apps.
I also don't understand what changed so drastically, as I was working fine until the day of my router going boom for no reason and doing a windows update, thinking it was rel